Thursday, November 19, 2026

Didn't Even Get My 15 Minutes!

I'm confident saying most people have at least one "small world" story they've recounted to others on more than occasion. I hope sharing mine will encourage you to do the same.

On vacation in 2015, the bus taking our Road Scholar group from Denali to Kenai Fords stopped at one of the few rest stops that appear on the only highway in Alaska connecting those two National Parks. While waiting on the rest room line, someone behind me called out "Pat Barton?" 

Yep, right there on that same line in that remote rest stop in the least populous state of the U.S. stood a student who had just been in a music class I'd finished the week before back in New Jersey. He'd heard me speaking to someone from our group while waiting, recognized my voice. Understandable, given he'd attended three two-hour sessions over the past three weeks. I dumbfoundedly replied "Bruce?", and we both burst out laughing. 

Best and worst part of my small world story? After getting back on the bus, several of my fellow travelers who'd overheard this uncanny exchange asked if I were famous. I quickly conjured an evasive and cryptic response. Unfortunately, fame was fleeting. My wife, by my side on that bus, immediately put a pin in that balloon. Darn.  

Monday, November 16, 2026

Jubilation

Asked to describe your state of mind since Election Day, what would you say?

Watching the results that night, I felt relief. Then, as the next several days unfolded, a lightness enveloped me that I hadn't even realized was missing until its return. 

Almost two weeks later, as the normal rhythms of life have resumed and the noise has diminished, my state of mind has landed on gratitude and hope. Gratitude for a sturdy democratic process combined with hope that the newly elected folks and their brethren will find a way to begin building a path to include people who don't share my jubilation about the results. 

Reflections from the Bell Curve: On This Night of the Day After

   

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Going Vs. Throwing

At this point, regular readers have likely grown accustomed to how frequently my partner of 48+ years appears in these reflections. Absent her grounding presence, my life could have easily spiraled into chaos long ago. Under certain circumstances, this becomes inescapably clear.  

For example, as the two of us finished preparations for a celebration we hosted earlier this week commemorating the 100th book/tenth anniversary of my book club, that steady hand of hers reminded me again how fortunate I am. At one point during the weeks leading up to the event, I tried to imagine what a party like this would look like without her common sense, attention to detail, and unerring ability to anticipate what our guests would enjoy. I had trouble conjuring anything short of a mess if she wasn't right there with me for every step.  

Though the events we've routinely hosted have steadily decreased in size, the time and effort we expend seems not to have decreased exponentially. In addition, the time we both need to recover has clearly increased. Still, we're not planning to stop just yet. I'm ready to continue being the go-fer, sous chef, and second fiddle in her orchestra as long as she remains willing and able to uphold our half century reputation for not-to-be-missed parties. And the fun the two of us have de-briefing and talking trash for days after - as well as all those yummy leftovers - makes it even less likely we'll be hanging up our party hats soon. 

Without her? This blogger will only be going to vs. throwing parties. Those of you who have attended one of ours? You better remember to invite me to yours. Promise I won't compare. 

Reflections from the Bell Curve: My True North


Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The Ready Answer to Why Not?

Reflections from the Bell Curve: Close to a Guarantee

Soon after publishing the post above, I was challenged - not for the first time - about my longstanding resolve to avoid bashing any author or book on my blog. The conversation began when a reader casually mentioned the number of authors and books I routinely endorse here, then asked if I'd ever considered having a separate blog exclusively devoted to literature. When I said I had given that idea serious thought early on - and had re-thought and dismissed doing so several times over the ensuing years - the conversation moved to a friendly challenge. 

The first part of that challenge was asking what my rationale is when deciding whether or not to publish a post about a specific book. Answering that was automatic because that rationale is the same as when I select a book for my own club or suggest one to a different club: 1.) The quality of the prose must meet my admittedly subjective standards and ... 2.) The book must have moved me, at minimum, or better, elevated me. All other factors - date of publication, subject matter, politics, narrative approach, profane or chaste, etc. - never enter the picture. If a book does the above, a future blog post is possible.    

Answering the follow-up question was more time-consuming but still manageable. "How often do you read a book that doesn't make your arbitrary cut?" (OK, maybe the "arbitrary" part there is less friendly but it's still a fair question.) Because the practice of keeping a book journal pre-dates my blog by just under one year - April 2010 vs. March 2011 - I then scoured the table of contents for each of my book journals - just started #9 for anyone vaguely interested - and tried to recall which of those books never showed up on my blog. I resisted actually counting - I swear - but was able to later resume the challenging conversation with an estimate. It was a substantial number.  

The final part of this recent challenge returned to solidly friendly territory with another question for which I had a ready answer. "Why not publish posts about some of those books that didn't move you?" (There was no mention in the last question about my snobbish requirement for quality prose.) Until I publish, self or otherwise, my own first long-form book, I have not earned the privilege to publicly bash - no matter how limited the reach of this blog - someone else's. 

Saturday, November 7, 2026

A Conflection

Several decades and an adult life with ample sin - none of it of a mortal stripe, thankfully - have passed since I last stepped into a confession booth. But confess I must. 

It took this lifelong movie aficionado a long time to begin regularly watching documentaries. 

I feel better already. And I'm open to whatever movie-connected penance any film geek who reads my blog thinks might help me further expiate my sin of omission. If you know of a pre-2010 documentary you think may have bypassed me in my wayward years, please share it here so that I can be cleansed.

Today's conflection took shape while I was being pummeled by You Can See Everything, the recently released documentary about Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos notoriety. I'm reasonably sure I'll be processing this disturbing multi-leveled film for weeks. Makes me wonder how many important documentaries escaped me despite my indiscriminate cinematic promiscuity. Forgive me father. 


Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Wanted: Catchy Title for Series

"Do I contradict myself? Very well then, I contradict myself. I am large; I contain multitudes.": Walt Whitman

Soon after publishing a post entitled Anchoring (Etc.) a few weeks back, it dawned on me how many times over sixteen years of blogging an alternative approach to a dilemma often occurs to me after I've released a reflection into the blogosphere. Am I saying I frequently need to contradict myself? Possibly. But even if saying that is not wholly accurate, it feels close enough that I'm ready to create a new series to potentially capture under one rubric all those instances when the use of words or phrases like "balance" or "fine line" or "perspective" seems mandatory. I'm open to suggestions for a catchy title and prefer something noble sounding. To be clear: Titles like The Wishy-Washy, Flip-Flopping, Perpetually Equivocating Blogger will not be considered. 

OK, back to the post called Anchoring (Etc.). Within minutes of hitting publish that day, I realized how I'd overlooked some critical elements therein connected to living a life of balance (there's that word). For example, that post advocated having clear strategies aimed at helping integrate new practices into daily life without mentioning the importance of being in the moment regularly, my rationale for starting a meditation practice over thirty-five years ago, anchoring aside. I also forgot to extol the value of frequent daydreaming, a reliable portal to creativity. And I neglected to speak of the fine line (see what I mean?) between being disciplined about our practices and simply allowing the restorative power of the natural world to work its magic on us daily. BTW, none of those critical elements require any anchoring. That was my perspective on that day. I guess that's understandable. I mean, this is my blog.   

While I'm waiting on your suggestions for a catchy title for this heretofore undeclared series, I've got almost 2700 posts to review to see which ones snugly fit this retroactive rubric. Will I re-name all of them using your noble-sounding goop? Stay tuned.     

Reflections from the Bell Curve: Anchoring (Etc.)

  

Sunday, November 1, 2026

Using the Signs

How easy it is to become used to things that are all around us. But while driving recently it suddenly dawned on me - I can make better use of signs to remind me of important stuff needing my attention. 


STOP:  Being judgmental
YIELD: To others with a different view
CAUTION:  Ambiguity ahead

If I remember to apply this new concept only each third time I see one of these ubiquitous signs, I'm batting .333 - hall of fame territory. I'll be thrilled to succeed just that often. What other signs are worth paying more attention to? What would you add to the sign? I think I'm onto something here - join me.

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Holding On

Twelve years ago, I began developing and teaching music courses for a robust lifelong learning program featured at a local community college. Although still not a foregone conclusion, at present it appears that program is wheezing toward its end. My time teaching at this college - the entree into an invigorating element of my third act - has been fulfilling from the start.    

What I'll miss most if this chapter of my life concludes - isn't this always the case? - are the people. Since 2014, I've had numerous moments of musical communion with many of the folks who have regularly attended my classes at this location. More than once, I've written of these moments here. Beginning my current class - which could be my last at this college - this past Thursday, I was once again rewarded when an astute student pointed out a lyrical subtlety in Don't Stand So Close to Me that had bypassed me despite having listened to that Police song repeatedly for over forty-five years.   

Have I had special moments like this at other places while teaching? Of course. However, knowing I may not have future opportunities to musically connect with some of these specific folks - a few have been with me from day one - gives me genuine pause. Label me sentimental; I've been called worse.

Good news to close. I've managed to build a bond with several of these repeat students outside the classroom. A few have joined my book club, several are now regular readers of my blog - one has become a prolific commenter - my wife and I have become close enough to one couple that we travelled with them early this year. The others? My plan is to collect as many e-mails as possible over the final two weeks of my current class in the hope that some of these folks may decide to attend a future course I'm conducting elsewhere. Completely abandoning a group of serious music lovers I've become attached to? No chance. 

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Culling

Ever known anyone who didn't collect something? If I have, that person does not come readily to mind. Ever wonder when this nearly universal propensity in homo sapiens began, i.e., once upon a time was it necessary to occasionally de-clutter our caves?  

As my later-in-life culling project continues apace, my reflections about collecting are, unsurprisingly, front and center. And though my collections of books and music paraphernalia never got really out of hand, it's been harder to part with that stuff than I sometimes admit. If you're at a similar juncture in your life - you know it's time to let go so that your adult children are not burdened with doing the culling after you're gone - which of your collections has given you the most pause? What useful culling strategies have you discovered that you can share here with me and others?

As the time approaches to jettison a lifetime of journals, medication might be required. 

Monday, October 26, 2026

Words for the Ages: Line Forty-Three

"We all have wings, but some of us don't know why."

Of the several long-running series created for my blog, Words for the Ages - now in its tenth year - seems to light a brighter fire than others, especially with respect to reader comments. Special thanks today to JT, who recently reminded me of the terse phrase above from an INXS song entitled Never Tear Us Apart. Today is the third instance when I've used a sharp reader's input to help keep this series vibrant and true to its mission.   

Who can reasonably dispute that some people go through life without realizing their potential? This essential truth is delivered in the phrase above via the use of wings as a metaphor; simple and elegant. Eleven words for the ages; concise, able to stand on their own, timeless. Although not often cited for his lyrics, Michael Hutchence, the charismatic lead singer of INXS, clearly hit the mark this time. Got a lyric you think conveys a similar message just as succinctly? Please share it here. I'm confident I'm not the only one interested.  

I'm paying close enough attention all the time to know there's a finite supply of these aphorisms disguised as song lyrics. However, I'm pleased to report some astute readers have apparently been inspired enough by recent iterations of Words for the Ages that they have given me a surplus to work from over the coming months. So, stay tuned commenters. That gem you suggested could be next. And big thanks for your help.


Friday, October 23, 2026

To Return or Not to Return?

Not long after leaving the full-time work world, I realized I needed a method to help me decide which authors I'd return to, given the number of reading years likely left to me. And until quite recently, I was reasonably happy with the method I settled on, i.e., if an author disappointed once - no matter how many winners had preceded that disappointment - I was done.

But soon after a satisfactory - although not mind-blowing - experience with an author new to me, I recognized the need to alter my sixteen-year-old model. This newer iteration is more flexible while retaining the needed discrimination of the original. See if you agree.

Heretofore, authors will be placed into one of three tiers for this reading snob:

a.) Those I will not return to, under any circumstances. The names of those authors will never be mentioned on this blog. Private conversations? A different kettle of fish.

b.) Those I might return to, if the right situation presents itself. More info on tier "b" available upon request. The author alluded to in the second paragraph above currently resides in tier "b". 

c.) Those I will return to, until they disappoint, at which point that author will move to tier "b." The number of disappointments allowed before being relegated to tier "a"? An open question.

Although curious to hear your thoughts on my flawless method, I'm even more curious to hear how it lines up - or does not - with your own. No judgments, or at least, not that many. 
          

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

A Familiar and Sacred Place

Taking for granted the natural beauty of familiar places is easy and unfortunate. 

Few things serve to remind me as much of this all-too-human tendency as early autumn in my beloved and lifelong home state. While on a recent hike at nearby Hartshorne Park, the symphony of colors and breathtaking view from an overlook above the Sandy Hook peninsula and Gateway National Recreation Area reminded me again how fortunate I am to be proximate to such splendor. I was not surprised hearing gasps from several of my hiking companions approaching that overlook. Lots of pictures were taken. None that I saw captured a fraction of the magic. Visit this website for an idea of what I re-experienced.
 

However, near the conclusion of the hike, our leader asked the group if anyone would like to take a few extra minutes and walk to the lighthouses that sit atop this magnificent spot. And though I'd been there before, the perfect weather, those majestic trees, and the fellowship of others who enjoy the outdoors capped off a peak morning. Though the picture below showcases a manmade vs. a natural feature, the cloudless blue sky enveloping that 1862 lighthouse brings back the wonder I experienced that day walking through a familiar and sacred place.



Saturday, October 17, 2026

Anchoring (Etc.)

When trying to integrate a new practice into your life - be it something mundane like flossing your teeth or something more substantive like regular exercising or reading more - what strategies have you found effective in helping the practice take hold?

I can't recall either how or when I first heard about the power of anchoring in helping a practice take hold. However, I do remember over thirty-five years ago deciding that integrating a meditation practice into my life was important. I also recall how much trouble I had at the time finding a consistent place and time to sit and pay attention only to my breathing. My daughter had just been born, I had a full time and two part-time jobs, life was pretty hectic. 

But the one thing I did Monday to Friday that I knew would not change anytime soon was driving to my full-time job in the a.m. Somehow (had I read about anchoring somewhere? did someone suggest it as a technique? did I identify it as anchoring after landing on my solution?), I came up with meditating in my car in a remote spot in the parking lot of my full-time work location. I left myself an extra half-hour each morning - which also helped me get up earlier and beat most of the rush hour traffic - and, except for days either too cold or too hot to sit in my car for thirty minutes, that consistent place and time issue was solved.

Rather than sharing other examples of how anchoring has worked for me, I'd prefer now to hear your strategies. Perhaps you've never specifically connected your success at integrating a new practice to anchoring it to something else in your life that is a constant. Even so, try re-creating your success story - as I did above - and then share here how you got there. Anchoring or not, maybe your story will help others who have struggled to find an effective way of getting a new practice to take hold. 

  

Thursday, October 15, 2026

Close to a Guarantee

Finishing The Correspondent (2025), my first thought was how could any open soul not like this book? Virginia Evans's debut novel is heartfelt, well-written, and totally engaging. Put aside its readability and humanness; it's also a bibliophile's dream. 
 
The letters sent and received by the protagonist - Sybil Van Antwerp - often refer to literature, one of her passions. In addition, Sybil is in the habit of writing to authors nearly as frequently as she writes to her brother Alex or best friend Rosalie. About halfway through this captivating novel, your favorite blogger - wearing his list making bibliophile hat - began keeping track of all the books and authors cited by Sybil and others, just in case one of you were to later wonder. The final tally? Around thirty-five. (Before you ask, yes, after beginning that list at the halfway point I did then return to the start to ensure the accuracy of the final number. Forgive me father.) 
 
Over the fifteen+ year history of my blog, I've published more than five hundred posts about books. And though every one of those five hundred moved me, for more than a few I felt it necessary to provide a caveat, about language, subject matter, density, etc. There is no caveat attached to my recommendation of The Correspondent. I'm confident this novel will appeal to almost any reader.

p.s. Over the same fifteen-year period, I've never published a single post about a book that left me cold. And there have been an ample number of those. 

Sunday, October 11, 2026

Listening to Myself in Act Three

Although flying back and forth between coasts for years now has had clear downsides, for this film geek, having a wide selection of films to choose from while in the air has almost evened the balance sheet. 

On this trip, I was enthralled end-to-end watching Disclosure Day. The nicest surprise? Stumbling across this engrossing and intelligent Stephen Spielberg film with no pre-knowledge. How can this be the case for an aficionado, you might reasonably ask. Several years ago, I made a resolution to try and bypass reviews and any "buzz" surrounding new books and films. As much as possible in Act Three, I now attempt to arrive at my own unvarnished opinion of the literature and movies I'm exposed to. I've done so with music most of my adult life. Why then the struggle throughout Act Two with my two other abiding passions? 

I've never been fully satisfied answering that question. In Act One of anyone's life, it's predictive - maybe unavoidable - for our opinions to be influenced by many things e.g., parents, peers, mentors, others more educated and experienced than our young selves. As we become actualized adults, those influences begin having less impact. But in my case, although the influence of parents and peers became less of a factor in Act Two, the voices of cultural critics seemed to grow. And the more esteemed the critic - Harold Bloom, John Leonard, James Wood - the more I found myself occasionally parroting their views. Why? Again, I'm still trying to land on a satisfactory answer to that. 

Hence, my Act Three resolve re movies and books. I have no idea what the critics have said about Disclosure Day. Because it's a Stephen Spielberg film, I'm reasonably confident there has been plenty of buzz. My daughter in the film industry certainly knew about it and asked me what I thought soon after we got to her place. My buzz to her? Clearly worth two+ hours, especially to distract myself while in the air, in a cramped seat, having difficulty concentrating on my book. What would John Leonard have had to say about this movie if he was still with us? Not sure. Hope I wouldn't have paid him any mind. 
  

Friday, October 9, 2026

A Friday Sermon

Holding myself accountable for consistently blogging for over fifteen years has given me a newfound respect for many things, including a few professions. Given my longtime agnosticism, perhaps the biggest surprise to me has been how much I've grown to appreciate members of the clergy.

Have you ever thought carefully about the amount of effort it takes to develop and deliver a sermon or homily every single week? I ask you to consider the following: 

* You're often speaking to many of the same people each week. So, how soon can you recycle stuff?
* You're drawing your material from the same - admittedly rich - source material each time. 
* You're speaking in a very quiet space, which means that aside from an occasional crying baby, nothing ever interrupts you. Net result: Every mispronounced or misused word is heard, every lapse in logic or flow is noticeable. 
* You're the center of attention for 10-15 minutes non-stop AND you have to draw a compelling conclusion.

Look at that list. How consistently well do you think you could do this? I've been in front of people as a musician, teacher, and speaker most of my professional life. But when I think about meeting all the requirements on that list, it gives me real pause. There are additional parallels with blogging - staying fresh, remaining relevant, keeping people interested/awake. Thank goodness I don't rely on people regularly tithing to keep this gig.

Monday, October 5, 2026

My Journey with Julian Barnes

Because Julian Barnes has indicated Departure(s) (2026) will be the last book of his career, soon after finishing it, I began reflecting on my twenty-year journey with this modern-day master. 

That journey started upon receiving Arthur and George (2005) as a gift from a member of my reading posse, in this case, my oldest niece. I've lost count how many new-to-me authors have later been added to my unmanageable "must return to" list after one of my posse have turned me onto them. That novel - Barnes's 10th as it turns out - ensured him a spot on that list.

I got my second taste of Barnes's undeniable gift when the first book club I ever joined selected The Sense of an Ending (2011). This was not long after I'd left the full-time work world and started my blog. I've since re-read that jewel three times, recommending it to every discerning reader I know. Additionally, I've mentioned it here at least a dozen times, in varying contexts. In my opinion, it is a nearly perfect novel.


Barnes's second memoir - Levels of Life (2013) - made it three for three. Then Elizabeth Finch (2022) marked the first time in my reading life to that point that an author hit four home runs in a row. I knew right then that Barnes's back catalog was in my reading future.


Most recently, another trusted member of my reading posse - this time the moderator of that same book club, now a good friend for fifteen years - suggested Departure(s) for the book club of two we kicked off twelve years back. As soon as she mentioned Barnes, I lunged at the opportunity to return to him. I didn't know when I started Departure(s) about this being his last book. But after he knocked me out, again, my resolve to return to his back catalog was fortified as this reflection began taking shape.
 
I'd welcome hearing about a journey you've taken with an author. How and when did it begin? Which events from your life coincided with the literary landmarks on that journey? Where are you headed next with that revered author?               
 

Friday, October 2, 2026

The Plan: 10/03/2040

Little man; Tomorrow you'll be two years young. You've already brought boundless joy to the lives of your mother and father and all four of your grandparents.

Reflections from the Bell Curve: Goal for Year 77

Several weeks after your first birthday last year, as pledged in the post above, I began a project for you - modeled after one I started for your mother when she turned eight - recounting my most cherished memories of some things we'd shared in the year that had just passed. My current plan - on your 16th birthday in 2040 - is to present you with a book much like the one I gave to your mother on her 21st birthday. Along with pictures from each year of your precious life will be all the hand-written letters I wrote to you, beginning with the one finished late last year. I'll begin my second letter sometime over the next week, i.e., what we've shared in the year between your first and second birthdays. 

On October 3, 2040, I'll be seven weeks away from my ninety first birthday. Here's what I hope will happen that day:  

* With your grandmother by my side, the three of us will take a walk to a local ice cream store, your book in hand. 

* The three of us (or five if Mom and Dad join us) will enjoy our ice cream while reading parts of the letters and looking at the pictures of you as you grew up.

* We'll laugh a lot. Then we'll walk home.     

I'm excited. 

Jeeps

Wednesday, September 30, 2026

#78: The Mt. Rushmore Series

Fresh on the heels of reprising my course on the Beatles - entitled The Magical Musical Mystery Tour - I decided the time was right to finally go on record with my Mt. Rushmore of Beatles songs. Without exaggeration, landing on just four songs from the Fab Four's catalog has taken me months of serious reflection. And I can hear your snark from here. Get a life, Pat. Sometimes - with respect to my veneration of the Beatles - I feel a bit like those Trekkies that William Shatner famously made fun of in that classic Saturday Night Live sketch many years back. 

Still, denying what the Beatles music has meant to me for over sixty years would be dishonest. So here they are, the four Beatles songs that have consistently meant the most to me, in alphabetical order. I don't claim these are the best Beatles songs; that's a fool's errand. Their catalog is too impossibly rich. Construct your Mt. Rushmore any way you wish. My only request: Please give me a rationale for your choices, i.e., what specifically moves you when listening to your Mt. Rushmore of Beatles songs? Because even writing about these four makes me vibrate. Honest. 

1.) And Your Bird Can Sing: Without question, the least well-known song on my monument, released in England on Revolver. Truth be told, not the best lyric John & Paul ever wrote. But put that aside and revel in the guitar harmonies - way before their time in popular music - and the way those three voices blend like blood. My goosebumps-guaranteed moment? The last verse ("You tell me that you've heard every sound there is ...") with that unmistakable Beatles-disguised-as-the-Everly Brothers descending harmony line. Musical alchemy.       

2.) If I Fell: The world would be an unquestionably smaller place without this jewel, a perfect pop song, if ever there was one. An eight-bar intro that nods toward Broadway, a unique musical ending for three of the four verses - including that exquisite tag - and two-part harmony from heaven.   

3.) In My Life: Where do I begin? With the lyric, indisputably one of the best end-to-end from the Beatles oeuvre? Ringo's subtle cymbal work? Which part? His syncopated hi-hat hits or the chiming quarter notes that ring off the bells of his ride cymbal? George Martin's elegant Baroque-style solo? Again, maybe those harmonies? The two-part stuff, i.e., John with Paul, or in those magical places where George briefly joins in? 

 Reflections from the Bell Curve: On The Record: The Beatles At Their Best

4.) Rain: When my blog was less than a month old, I published the post above, being careful to say at the time that this was the "Beatles at their best", not the "best" Beatles song; there is no such thing. This under-played gem has everything. I wouldn't change a word I wrote over fifteen years ago any more than I would tell the lads to change a single thing they did when they wrote and recorded this timeless treasure sixty years ago.   

I'm waiting. Don't let me down, Beatles geeks. (Get it?) Give me your Mt. Rushmore, please.

Monday, September 28, 2026

Majestic Moments


Had I seen Michael Keaton's extraordinary turn in The Whisper Man before publishing the post above, there's no question he would have been one of the four actors I enshrined on iteration #72 in my most enduring series. Keaton's work in this recently released Netflix film is the personification of a well-known actor playing against type. 

Given its creepy premise, The Whisper Man is not for everyone. Robert DeNiro is predictably excellent playing a haunted retired police detective. And both Adam Scott - as DeNiro's estranged son - and Michelle Monaghan, playing a detective investigating a series of brutal crimes, hold their own alongside the master. But Keaton's three scenes - the first with DeNiro and Monaghan, then one with DeNiro alone, and the last, an indescribably perverse scene near the end of the film - feature him at the peak of his craft. I would willingly watch this disturbing movie a second time just to re-experience Keaton's artistry. The closest recent analogues I've had have been after finishing Daniel Woodrell's The Death of Sweet Mister (2001) early this month and re-listening - for perhaps the 1000th time - to If I Fell while preparing to teach a class on the Beatles in August. In these majestic moments, my life is immeasurably enriched. When have you most recently been transported by great art, no matter the medium?     
     
Although I suspect I'll be disappointed, I'm still hoping Keaton gets a best supporting actor nod when next year's Oscars are announced. If you watch The Whisper Man, I'm curious to hear your reaction.