About Me

My photo
To listen to my latest recording, view my complete profile and then click on "audio clip" under "links"

Saturday, May 23, 2020

An Unnecessary, Irrelevant, Redundant Ailment

Lifelong list makers: How would you compare the number of lists you currently start to the number you routinely started pre-Wikipedia? How many of your long-held lists have you discarded since Wikipedia rendered our obsessive need to maintain those lists unnecessary?

During a recent game in the Trivial Pursuit-athon my wife and I initiated after this health crisis began, I was reminded again how irrelevant my lists have become. But such is my ailment that soon after asking folks in that game which film depiction of a fictional US president was their favorite, my first thought was "Do I have a list of those films somewhere?" Honest. For the record, my favorite fictional president is Morgan Freeman in the cheesy Deep Impact. Henry Fonda is in second place in a better movie - Fail Safe - closely followed by Gene Hackman in Absolute Power, another good film. Which three fictional film presidents make up your holy trinity?

Turns out I had no list like this anywhere. Unfortunately, that sent my addled brain into overdrive soon after the ZOOM TP game ended. I began parsing other distinctions regarding movies and US presidents. Which is my favorite film depiction of an actual US president? (Which one is yours?) Which actors - other than Henry Fonda - have played both fictional and actual presidents? How many actors - other than Gene Hackman - have played a fictional president in more than one film? How many of our presidents have been depicted in movies to date? Which of our little recalled presidents has been depicted? When I got stuck on that last question - with no list of my own to consult - I was grateful Wikipedia had it covered; a few keystrokes and then...relief.


Pre-Wikipedia, this kind of ephemera would have driven this list making movie geek to distraction, devouring precious hours. Got to love a tool that frees up enough time for me to make a list of all my discarded lists that the same tool has now made redundant. 


  1. I'd like some clarity on "lifelong list makers." "List makers" should not be a general category of people. Although I would have described myself as a list maker prior to this blog, there exists no list of mine that can be discarded with the advent of Wikipedia. Can Wikipedia complete a task or accomplish a goal? Lists are not lists that cannot be crossed off.

    1. JM; So the lists you're talking about (to do's, groceries, etc.) are what I'd call utilitarian and can't - as you said - be discarded because of Wikipedia, obviously. And this "lifelong list maker" has lots of those all the time and gets immense (perverse?) satisfaction scratching stuff off of them. But ... for a list-making geek like me, those are just the tip of the iceberg list-wise. And that's where Wikipedia has helped lighten my "lifelong" burden. This is definitely the subject of a near-future conversation my dear JM.