Of the many rationales I've heard from men throughout my life - starting with my father - why they don't read fiction, the one that has most consistently befuddled me is "I read for information."
While immersed in Imagine Me Gone (2016), there were moments when my befuddlement with that rationale took on an odd aspect. Adam Haslett's novel - told by five first person narrators - examines the toll that mental illness invariably takes on a family. It is often painfully sad. But as I finished, it occurred to me that some of the sadness I felt during this exceptional reading experience might be connected to men I've known who "read for information". Given those limits, isn't it likely Haslett's masterful exploration of the human condition would bypass most of them? Predictably, the men most dear to me who would've been excluded, including my Dad, were foremost in my reflections.
Of course, any man - those in my life or otherwise - could easily read a textbook, non-fiction account of any length, case study, etc., covering mental illness vs. family dynamics for "information". I submit none of that information would stay with any man - or woman - like Imagine Me Gone will stay with me.
I agree. A novel can put us in touch with the emotional realm in a way that non-fiction usually can't.
ReplyDeleteInes; Thanks for the comment and concurrence.
DeleteI believe it is Sherman Alexie's book THE LONG RANGER AND TONTO FISTFIGHT IN HEAVEN (surely one of the best titles of all time) which has an epigraph from his old writing teacher: "If it's fiction, it better be true." Nuff said.
ReplyDeleteJim; Thanks for weighing in and for the apt the Sherman Alexie quote.
DeleteHey Pat. Although I enjoy, very much, reading Non-Fiction there are more times than not that when I pick up a book it is Fiction. I do read for information and I get a lot of that from the news sources I follow but, for the most part, when I read I read for enjoyment and Fiction tends to do that for me more than Non-Fiction. Not always, but usually.
ReplyDeleteBe well,
Bob
Bob; Thanks for a new record-setting day for your comments across several different posts. You're a mensch!
Delete