In my experience, people are usually disappointed when novels are adapted to film; I largely share this viewpoint. Which of you has experienced a rare reversal, i.e. when a movie adapted from a book is better than the original?
I recently re-watched "Jaws", a terrific action movie with three exceptional lead performances, including a young Richard Dreyfuss. As I watched it, I recalled the Peter Benchley book the film was based on. For any of you who read and remember that book, I'm curious if you would agree that this is indeed a rare reversal. More to the point, which novel to film adaptations represent a rare reversal for you?
How about a "less" rare reversal (at least I think it's less rare)? What was the last song you heard remade that you felt surpassed the original? I know this is an apples to oranges comparison but it intrigues me, I'm interested in your views, and after all, this is my blog so I can ask whatever I want.
About Me
- Pat Barton
- My most recent single release - "My True North" - is now available on Bandcamp. Open my profile and click on "audio clip".
A rare reversal-The Secret Life of Bees movie was 5 star. The book was just okay. The casting was excellent, and the set. My eyes could not take in everything at once nor could I get enough. Also the music by Liz Wright (new artist for me) added mood to the movie. I just had to download Liz Wright the next day.
ReplyDeleteI read "Bees.." also and must have liked it more than you. But...I haven't seen it yet so based on your recommendation I'll make sure I do.
ReplyDeleteThanks for all your comments.
I agree with Jaws - that movie affected me more than almost any other book or movie.
ReplyDeleteAs for songs, Linda Ronstadt has some awesome remakes - well maybe almost everything she did was a remake. Her "Desperado" destroys the Eagles' version (who I'm also a fan of). And, she owns Blue Bayou . . .
I'm a huge Beatles fan, but really like Eddie Vedder's "You've Got To Hide Your Love Away". Israel Kamakawiwo'ole's "Over the Rainbow". You could have a whole separate blog on this topic.